I know we're not running out of themes any time soon; I've already got stamps made for a theme for each cycle, and I'm also planning a Winner Theme (Adrianne, Yoanna, Eva, Naima, etc) for the winners up through whichever cycle has recently finished when I do the theme.
Below you will find some other ideas I've had for themes, in order to keep the community active as long as possible.
-Runner-Up Theme (would consist of the runner-up from each cycle; Shannon, Mercedes, Yaya, Kahlen, Nik, etc. up through the cycle that has just finished when I do the theme)
-Judging Panel/Coaches Theme would include Tyra, Janice, Twiggy, Paulina, Kimora, the Jays, Nigel, Nole, Sutan, etc. (Please note that this theme includes both male and female options, so obviously some people will end up with someone they don't look exactly like.)
-Personal Style Theme: Would include contestants with distinctive personal styles, like Camille (C2), Nicole(C3), Kim(C5), Jael(C8), Celia(C12), etc. This theme would include questions and pictures, and voting would be based on the type of clothes the person wears rather than their appearance. I would put up a poll before this theme asking for opinions on whose personal style you think is interesting or distinctive (whether you like it or not).
-The "Which Cycle Would You Have Fit In" theme is just what it sounds like, which group of contestants do you look like you'd belong with?
-Photoshoot Theme: Would include some of the more interesting/distinctive photoshoots from the show, and would include both questions and pictures. This would be to determine which photoshoot you would've totally rocked.
If you have any other ideas for what you'd like to see, mention it in a comment. Please note that strictly personality-based "which contestant are you like?" themes aren't going to be available here; there's already a very nice personality-based ANTM stamping community for that and you can find a link in the profile page. :)
On to the poll!
Which themes would you like to see? Check as many as you like.
Judging Panel/Coaches Theme
Personal Style Theme
Which cycle would you have fit in?
Other (Specify in comments!)